The Rutgers Law Record
https://lawrecord.com/111714-associate-editor-posts/
Export date: Wed Nov 18 19:06:01 2026 / +0000 GMT

11/17/14: Associate Editor Posts


For Public or For Profit? University Property Tax-Exempt Status Challenged


By Min Xue


Traditionally, universities are given tax-exempt status under both federal and state law supported by the notion that schools, as educational institutions, provide public benefits, and are therefore worthy of public support. However, these days many universities engage in commercial activities such as patent and trademark licensing, venture capital, retail business, real estate, and certain investment operations that may be profit seeking in nature. The changing universities' behavior of mixing educational and non-educational activities has raised questions as to whether they are worthy of tax exemption status any more.

Residents of the Borough of Princeton challenged Princeton University's property tax-exempt status by filing a complaint alleging that the school violated the New Jersey tax-exempt provisions by earning hundreds of millions of dollars in patent royalty income, among other commercial enterprises, and sharing that income with certain faculty members.

New Jersey statute N.J.S.A 54:4-3.6 sets forth the qualifications for an exempt organization. As illustrated in Paper Mill Playhouse v. Township of Millburn, three criteria must be met under the statute: (1) the organization that owns the property must be organized exclusively for exempt purposes; (2) its property must be actually and exclusively used for the tax-exempt purpose; and (3) the organization's operation and use of its property must not be conducted for profit.

With respect to the first prong, it is not arguable that Princeton is organized for a non-profit purpose. With respect to whether the individual buildings are actually and exclusively used for the tax-exempt purpose, it comes down to the function of each building and how the profits are utilized. The third prong appears to be the most difficult one, which is whether the university itself operates for profit. If the court finds Princeton University is operating for profit, invalidation of its property tax-exempt status in total may be warranted. If the commercial activities conducted by the university exceed the scope of educational purpose, the university is more akin to a profit-making corporation in essence, which may no longer be worthy of public support.

 

Game-changer in Silicon Valley


By Stephen Sainato


There exists a recent controversy surrounding the “employer-provided meals” in Silicon Valley at companies such as Google and Facebook. Currently, employees, as a perquisite of working at one of these companies, can indulge in virtually endless amounts of “free” food—from snacks to fine dining prepared by top chefs. As a top priority for the upcoming fiscal year, the I.R.S. is considering the taxability of such “free” food. The main issue is whether the employees must include its “employer-provided meals” as taxable income, measured by the fair market value of the meals.

Generally, employees enjoy the ability to exclude these meals from their taxable income if two tests are met: (i) the meals are furnished on the business premises of the employer; and (ii) the meals are furnished for the convenience of the employer. The I.R.S. has been and will likely continue to be arguing such meals to this extent should be taxable fringe benefits, while employers are arguing these meals should remain excludable from income and thus non-taxable. The new “guidance” to be issued by the I.R.S. will almost unquestionably result in a heated debate, and many are predicting the debate to find its way into the courts.

By allowing employers to provide perquisites like these, which can amount to a significant value, the economy is distorted and can equip some employers with an unfair advantage over other employers since these perquisites can be tax deductible for employers and non-includable as taxable income for employees. The new regulation that is forecasted to be provided by the I.R.S. relatively soon, will likely cause a significant impact on corporations—forcing them to restructure their compensation packages and revisit their tax planning strategies.

 

“Welfare as ‘we' know it”


By Dan Giordano


When the conditions in the economy are such that the cost of poor relief rises, reform movements begin the work of persuading the public that it needs to, in President Clinton's phrase, “end welfare as we know it.” The modern state is often described as the “welfare state” in part because reform movements have convinced the people that they ended welfare as they knew it and therefore the lessons from the significant history of civil poor relief are forgotten.

Welfare as we know it (PROWRA) is a cooperative federalism program where a block grant is given to states for poor relief to families provided that the states expend a benchmark amount on programs which further the purpose of the modern law. This provides flexibility to the states to administer to the poor in a variety of ways while also recognizing that there is a national interest in administering to the poor throughout the United States.

Block grants are a two-sided coin however. On the other side of flexibility is abuse of that discretion. Since the Great Recession began, states began looking for funding loopholes in their budgets. They began to take programs which were previously funded independently and placed them in the matching funds requirement for the PROWRA grant. This in effect displaced the funds which were supposed to be spent on poor relief. Today only 27% of welfare spending is on basic assistance.

Welfare as we know it began as a quiet section of the Social Security Act. It was meant to eliminate problems associated with settlement requirements by recognizing a national interest in administering to the poor. It was to be coupled with a local administrative structure which devolved discretion to counties and localities. This basic structure of national funding and local administration was a synthesis of the poor relief which had been administered in this country since the colonial period and in England since the early 17th century.

The Elizabethan system was funded locally and administered locally. This, however, became extraordinarily expensive during the transition from agrarian to industrialization. The towns which saw their poor rates accelerate were also the towns impacted most by this transition in the economy and they more rapidly disappeared because of the local responsibility to fund the poor relief.

The reform movement which followed exposed the futility of local funding/local administration of poor relief. Its unsuccessful solution, though was national funding for national administration. This method of poor relief was administered for almost 100 years until the modern welfare state was “born” in the 1930's. The rigidity necessary to administer poor relief nationally is familiar to popular culture in Dickensian poor-houses and Chaplin films. Thus the history of poor relief points towards a nationally funded and locally administered poor relief.

While there is much criticism of the modern welfare state, it may be the best available way to administer to the poor. However, the flaws of loopholes in cooperative federalism has distorted the amount spent funding welfare yielding inefficient delivery and the professionalization of what was once a social service in the bureaucracy has standardized the distribution of poor relief according to the rigid guidelines that proved ineffective according to Charles Dickens. This has consequently distorted the structure of civil poor relief which we are the fortunate heirs of, that is local administration of national poor relief.

However, Paul Ryan's recent plan may provide the necessary solution. His plan is to put local charity networks in competition with each other for their performance in moving people off welfare. Cutting out a professionalized bureaucracy and restoring local social workers role in the administration of poor relief may be the best way to reform welfare as we know it using what we've learned from welfare as our ancestors knew it.

 

A Photo Worth a Thousand Words


By Laura Schuman


Our image is one of our most valuable assets. It can convey our deepest feelings and emotions and reveal to the world our truest selves. But the copyright to these images can belong to a stranger. All rights to sell, alter, or publish lie with a man or woman whom we may hire to take photos of a very special occasion or intimate moment that we may intend only for our own enjoyment and not for the prying eyes of others.

In examining the Federal Copyright Act and the “work for hire” provision, it is clear that copyright ownership in these images all lay with the photographer by default. From experience, photographers are not quick to part with this right and if they do concede copyright in images they took, it comes at a very high price. The historic reasoning for why the copyright vests in the photographer is because they are seen as the artist who created the setting, the costume, and evoked the emotion of the subject. But this was based on the old practice of studio portraiture. It does not take in to account the exponential growth in the field of photography, the predominance of internet use in today's world, and the creation of social media platforms.

It is therefore necessary to look to state laws governing the rights of privacy or rights of publicity to determine how we can protect ourselves, as individual consumers, from this very literal taking of our images; our identities; our most valuable asset as people in this age of technology. In the moment it takes to click a button and publish a photo on the “world wide web”, our reputations can be damaged, our relationships harmed, and our most intimate secrets placed on display for public consumption. This seems even stranger when we are the ones paying for these images to be created in the first place.

We should explore the roots and potential remedies for both the photographer (as an “artist”) and the individual consumer so both can profit without harming the other. Hopefully, we can come to a delicate balance between full copyright ownership and what this means in a very real sense for today's unwitting consumer hiring a professional to take photos of them and their loved ones, and the potential repercussions for doing so.

 

Solitary Confinement of Transgender Prisoners


By Pooja Patel


Many transgender inmates—particularly women—are not housed in cells with other inmates of their preferred gender, supposedly because prison personnel are concerned about a high risk of sexual assault. Instead, transgender inmates are often placed in solitary confinement or some type of solitary segregation, while other inmates charged with the same crime are placed in cells that afford them more freedom of movement and human contact. The primary reason given for the continuation of this practice is to protect the safety of the inmate. However, placement in solitary often leads to even greater instances of sexual assault, as the actions of prison guards are less accountable in less-public locations. Moreover, in addition to the torturous toll that solitary confinement places on any human being, transgender prisoners are particularly punished, because they are separated and forced to do time in conditions that no not match their behavior or the crime for which they were convicted.

Several other articles have argued how solitary confinement of transgender detainees is unconstitutional (based on an 8th Amendment/cruel and unusual theory), or how segregation of transgender inmates should be treated with stricter scrutiny than rational basis. Instead, we should focus on analyzing existing policy guidelines. One other article, written about five years ago, loosely takes this approach, but there don't seem to be any academic articles that cover newer developments. We should also examine alternatives, drawing on alternatives proposed by authors of other articles. Last, and most importantly, we should explore case law in various jurisdictions and evaluate the possible constitutional legal claims that can be brought by transgender inmates who are segregated from the general inmate population based on their gender expression rather than their actions.
Post date: 2014-11-17 10:49:38
Post date GMT: 2014-11-17 17:49:38

Post modified date: 2014-11-17 10:50:54
Post modified date GMT: 2014-11-17 17:50:54

Export date: Wed Nov 18 19:06:01 2026 / +0000 GMT
This page was exported from The Rutgers Law Record [ https://lawrecord.com ]
Export of Post and Page has been powered by [ Universal Post Manager ] plugin from www.ProfProjects.com